Kirk Houghton

Author of The Dividing Lines and Bad Things to Good People
Kirk's Book Reviews
Kirk's Book Reviews
Review of Moral Tribes: Emotion, Reason and the Gap Between Us and Them by Joshua Greene
Posted on March 29, 2016 at 5:10 PM |
Moral Tribes: Emotion, Reason, and the Gap Between Us and Them by Joshua Greene
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
A Harvard Professor aiming at the hearts and minds of anoraks and airport-dwellers everywhere is a publisher’s dream and will often result in that rarest of phenomenon – a Philosophy text that shifts tens of thousands of units in the English-speaking world. No wonder Atlantic seized the chance to get a High Brow work into the all-important book stands at Hudson and WH Smith on both sides of the pond. Give the book an eye-catching title and a monumental subject and watch the sales roll in. But is commercial success a useful indicator of intellectual success?
Drawing on the latest developments in Social Biology, Moral Psychology and Cultural Anthropology, Moral Tribes is a thoughtful book that is destined to receive wider currency amongst policymakers and large sections of civic society. At the very least it will confirm Joshua Greene as a superstar in academic circles. Yet one cannot help feeling this is a commendable but flabby effort littered with superfluities.
At 353 pages in length, Moral Tribes is a strong defence of Utilitarianism, the nineteenth-century philosophical creed of John Stuart Mill and Jeremy Bentham; but is that enough to justify such a vast undertaking? A constant reminder that humans are tribal creatures that are good at solving the ‘Me versus Us’ problems of cooperation but weak at tackling the ‘Us versus Them’ urgencies of modern life is not exactly new, but Greene is wise to structure his argument around this theme with the aid of the ubiquitous ‘Prisoner’s Dilemma’ scenarios beloved of his profession. So what is he saying beneath the onslaught of empirical science?
In a nutshell, human brains work like dual-process cameras. We have an Automatic mode (the Ventromedial Prefrontal Cortex) that has evolved over millions of years to help us overcome the problem of inter-tribal cooperation, and a Manual mode (the Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex) that is used when our gut feelings and emotions fail us. Morality is, in Greene’s words, ‘a series of psychological adaptations that allow otherwise selfish individuals to reap the benefits of cooperation.’ But morality evolved ‘to promote cooperation within groups for the sake of competition between groups.’ In other words, the tension between these two competing forces is the source of our tribalism. Having more faith in our Manual mode is the key to developing larger outer-group cooperation and expanding beyond parochialism. Greene hopes a better understanding of this juxtaposition should allow us to re-appraise the benefits of utilitarian thinking and frame our cooperative decisions and moral choices in pursuit of policies that promote the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people.
Yet devoting two chapters to the dual process brain is a lot of effort for the sake of making a classical Liberal philosophy essential once again. And herein lies the fundamental weakness of the book – despite a succinct title and ambitious topic this really is more of a patchwork concoction of ideas lacking a coherent direction. The intellectual scope is not in doubt, nor is the warm and engaging tone that makes this such an enjoyable read. But at the core of Moral Tribes is a chasm between the reader’s expectation and the author’s delivery.
Nevertheless, you will still get a lot out of this study. Part One of Moral Tribes is a masterful summary of how morality has evolved in human decision-making, including the emotions that dictate our actions and how we’ve developed complex feelings such as empathy and indignation at perceived injustices enacted against people we don’t know. Likewise, Part Five is a skilled attempt to argue the case for John Stuart Mill. For all his greatness, Aristotle gives us parochial morals codes that cannot answer universal truths; Kant’s belief that morality is quantifiable, like mathematics, is still found wanting. We need Utilitarianism just as much as ever.
But in Greene’s view, Utilitarianism is a misleading term that ought to be replaced by ‘Deep Pragmatism.’ And he is right in one observation: the misguided belief that Bentham and Mill’s utility calculus fetishizes rationality above all other considerations to the point of undermining the core of humanity is blinding us to the reality of its benefits. Even more alarming, the few philosophers that still look to Kant for guidance receive more intellectual approbation than the lonely Benthamites of this world. No wonder moral relativism (the idea that no culture or morality is superior to others) reigns supreme in our current politics.
It’s therefore refreshing to hear Greene challenge the status quo by daring to suggest there might be a universal morality that is worth striving for in pursuit of a better future. In his view, hiding behind ‘rights’ in public debate is a cowardly way to close off our Manual brain settings when they are most needed. And his thorough examination of the abortion debate in contemporary America is easily the most sober and iconoclastic examination I’ve read to date. As one experiment shows, people often have a strong opinion on something when they don’t understand the full complexities; ask them to explain their understanding of a topic and they are more likely to moderate their stance and consider alternatives. This being the case, the answer is staring us in the face: our democracy needs more ‘deep pragmatists’ in public office. What a surprise!
Though an underwhelming conclusion, don’t let this discourage you from reading Moral Tribes. Greene’s writing is clear and engaging, considerate yet incisive, and intelligent enough to infuse complex scientific topics with humour. If there’s one thing you’ll get out of this, it’s a desire to enrol on one of his undergraduate courses or download the podcasts.
Perhaps the next book will make him an undisputed star in his field, but for now we have an implicit plea to improve our democratic decision-making with utilitarian reasoning instead of the rationalisations we now use to justify our emotional prejudices.
Unfortunately, with Donald Trump on the verge of winning the Republican Presidential nomination, this looks further away than ever.
Categories: None
Post a Comment
Oops!
The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.
159 Comments

https://wakelet.com/wake/4p8MBpSZ-sgSFeJQFQoFB
https://wakelet.com/wake/SADabO1788zcqKKgcmddi
https://wakelet.com/wake/xfcoaUZxA7_-2sOhrRgXN
https://wakelet.com/wake/Cw8oXteKInsKBBzwFy5v1
https://wakelet.com/wake/eS-fOy6_UA1cBrwWvyf-M
https://wakelet.com/wake/ZWytc0VSO6JqMmnZRzbAg
https://wakelet.com/wake/SWK1xupKeEWybw0nGp7WX
https://wakelet.com/wake/vs1Z6WpVt1nxKWXs4OiE_
https://wakelet.com/wake/PbTZpNxCxMbhQ2kpukSRg

uct-activation-serial-number-exclusive-free
https://coub.com/stories/3102812-terjemahan-kitab-al-wajiz-pdf-23
2
https://coub.com/stories/3102811-full-nextel-motorola-iden-rss-ca
rrier-20-and-depot-20-2021
https://coub.com/stories/3102810-hot-aashiqui-2-movie-tamil-dubbe
d-free-312
https://coub.com/stories/3102809-obscurity-serial-number-link
https://coub.com/stories/3102807-siemens-step-7-microwin-v4-0-ful
l-new-rar
https://coub.com/stories/3102808-long-war-with-cracked-30-link
https://coub.com/stories/3102805-systat-tablecurve-2d-v501rar-upd
https://coub.com/stories/3102803-adobe-illustrator-cs3-verified-c
rack-only
https://coub.com/stories/3102806-windows-7-8-8-1-10-loader-activa
tor-v6-1-12-reloaded-rar-bevgin

-key-shilau
https://coub.com/stories/2989415-krishna-aur-kans-movie-dual-audi
o-720p-download-__hot__
https://coub.com/stories/2989412-rpp-berkarakter-agama-kristen-pr
otestan-sd-kelas-1-6-rar
https://coub.com/stories/2989409-activador-de-office-x-venetian-d
elvine
https://coub.com/stories/2989406-better-luxor-5th-passage-downloa
d-low-pc
https://coub.com/stories/2989404-__hot__-universal-shield-v4-7-cr
acked-repack-brd-rar-129311
https://coub.com/stories/2989402-heavy-metal-movie-full-fix-versi
on-1981
https://coub.com/stories/2989403-brian-lara-international-cricket
-2007-crack-file-free-download-portable
https://coub.com/stories/2989401-automation-studio-6-download-cra
ck-rhijale
https://coub.com/stories/2989399-hd-online-player-solucionario-de
-wade-5ta-edicion-org-patched

ck-13
https://coub.com/stories/3088758-kamala-krithivasan-automata-pdf-
portable-free-16
https://coub.com/stories/3088757-shimla-mirchi-tamil-full-movie-h
d-1080p-free-download-repack
https://coub.com/stories/3088751-hd-online-player-veerey-ki-weddi
ng-full-movie-free-do-link
https://coub.com/stories/3088753-wondershare-recoverit-8-1-2-3-cr
ack-setup-free-osmosymo
https://coub.com/stories/3088749-milf-named-meg-450-pics-rar
https://coub.com/stories/3088748-interspire-email-marketer-versio
n-6-1-5-nulled-30l-mallbern
https://coub.com/stories/3088743-xf-adsk2015-x64-exe-epub
https://coub.com/stories/3088742-5dfly-photo-design-4-1-56-serial
-number
https://coub.com/stories/3088741-autodata-2009-v3-24-new-keygen-r
ar

ratorhttps-scoutmails-com-index301-php-k-bosch-esi-tronic-key
https://coub.com/stories/3111847-_hot_-jasc-paint-shop-pro-8-free
-download-full-version
https://coub.com/stories/3111846-updated-revit-2016-32-bit-crack-
torrent-download
https://coub.com/stories/3111845-milica-knjazevac-sa-dvojicom-69-
exclusive
https://coub.com/stories/3111844-company-of-heroes-cheat-engine-t
able-6-2-11-oldedar
https://coub.com/stories/3111843-sibelius-v6-0-0-54-nope-crack-to
p
https://coub.com/stories/3111842-corona-renderer-4-hotfix-1-for-3
ds-max-2013-2020-exclusive
https://coub.com/stories/3111841-abbyy-finereader-10-0-102-130-co
rporate-edition-multilang-serial-key-keygen-hot
https://coub.com/stories/3111840-microsoft-mappoint-europe-2013-t
orrent-elljale
https://coub.com/stories/3111839-descargar-solucionario-ciencia-m
ateriales-para-ingenieros-shackelford-pdf

bed-hindi-daviqun
https://coub.com/stories/2959867-splinter-cell-conviction-data9-c
ab-full-download-rar-work
https://coub.com/stories/2959864-jigs-w-puzzle-2-platinum-version
-2-42-serial-197
https://coub.com/stories/2959863-rudra-ghana-patha-pdf-gysbern
https://coub.com/stories/2959859-absynth-5-crack-torrent-full-25-
vanyodyl
https://coub.com/stories/2959857-mettle-mantra-vr-v1-27-full
https://coub.com/stories/2959856-total-war-shogun-2-v1-0-0-build-
3241-10-59-verified
https://coub.com/stories/2959855-hd-online-player-operation-flash
point-red-river-launc-shaualex
https://coub.com/stories/2959853-tone2electraxcrack-portable
https://coub.com/stories/2959854-fsx-larnaca-x-rip-hack-torrent-h
altleo

hindi-720p-download-portable
https://coub.com/stories/3015025-cracked-tachosoft-mileage-calcul
ator-23-1
https://coub.com/stories/3015018-free-miner-max-download-full-ver
sion-92
https://coub.com/stories/3015016-wind-loads-for-petrochemical-and
-other-industrial-facilities-new
https://coub.com/stories/3015012-cat-sis-2011b-crack-epub-work
https://coub.com/stories/3015013-extra-quality-teowin-v6-para-tar
inga
https://coub.com/stories/3015009-mentor-graphics-pads-9-5-crack-e
milnav
https://coub.com/stories/3015008-doodle-army-2-mini-militia-v2-2-
9-mod-unlocked-apk-xpoz-6-top
https://coub.com/stories/3015007-_best_-orcs-must-die-2-full-crac
k-full
https://coub.com/stories/3015006-crackcoreldrawx5psikeydll-winber
n

r-the-ultimate-collection-torrent
https://coub.com/stories/2964550-new-additional-mathematics-ho-so
o-thong-pdf-rar-hot
https://coub.com/stories/2964547-_best_-dwg-trueview-2017-32bit-k
eygen-xforce
https://coub.com/stories/2964546-brother-pe-design-6-0-embroidery
-software-without-need-for-dongl-verified-full-version
https://coub.com/stories/2964545-adobe-photoshop-cs6-13-0-extende
d-final-multilanguage-patch-pai-64-bit-xavyjuli
https://coub.com/stories/2964544-configurar-router-conceptronic-c
54apra2-como-repetidor
https://coub.com/stories/2964543-hot-fsx-oejn-jeddah-king-abdul-a
ziz-airport-by-bdo-aviation-hack-online
https://coub.com/stories/2964541-work-audaces-vestuario-9-mega
https://coub.com/stories/2964537-crackpianissimovirtualgrandpiano
-_best_
https://coub.com/stories/2964534-mobione-studio-full-cracked-37-2
021

802-11-n-wlan-download-for-18
https://ampublunchrencartt.wixsite.com/cammicktersa/post/adobe-an
imate-cc-2019-19-0-0-full-64bit-license-patch-zip
https://cessgenanra1981.wixsite.com/agmoserpa/post/gom-cam-2-0-2-
1517-crack-serial-key-2020-download
https://cessgenanra1981.wixsite.com/agmoserpa/post/prominy-v-meta
l-kontakttorrent
https://ecancriseagsnow.wixsite.com/slavpewiti/post/subtitles-mbr
-regenera-free-avi-dual-720
https://immizvicentcheret.wixsite.com/rilicage/post/download-wind
ows-media-player-12-0-76
https://viktorshcherbakov87.wixsite.com/misginiku/post/ladies-vs-
ricky-bahl-movie-download-in-hindi-720p-torrent
https://nacymousgirokafnes.wixsite.com/worthbarrioro/post/1080p-m
y-time-at-portia-watch-online-2k-watch-online
https://jaeeurbin331m7t.wixsite.com/baatraddescfer/post/downloadf
ilmakb48majisukagakuensubindo
https://barbplancarte118nf.wixsite.com/makatiso/post/phantom-full
-movie-in-tamil-download-movie

tada-pdf-pdfl
https://coub.com/stories/3261267-new-loving-annabelle-2006-dvdrip
-xvidneptune
https://coub.com/stories/3261233-free-gta-iv-complete-edition-gta
-4-eflc-multi-5-repack-pc
https://coub.com/stories/3261261-typing-master-full-version-with-
crack-best
https://coub.com/stories/3261259-updated-free-download-hindi-movi
e-rocket-singh-salesman-of-the-year
https://coub.com/stories/3261258-aida64-extreme-engineer-5-97-460
0-serial-key-better-keygen
https://coub.com/stories/3261253-nayak-hd-video-songs-720p-mkv-da
rhila
https://coub.com/stories/3261248-chithra-in-nair-studio-pdf-tamil
-sex-35-updated
https://coub.com/stories/3261246-download-free-auto-lip-sync-afte
r-effects-plugins-top
https://coub.com/stories/3261244-utorrent-cpasbien-dexter-saison-
7-french

https://wakelet.com/wake/EQ5ZxY-y3EY2ellVk2I2v
https://wakelet.com/wake/CdfgKCtgaAva7ai9KYxne
https://wakelet.com/wake/4wg91Fo_W4sRKeOXfLEiO
https://wakelet.com/wake/zudpMkHPtDdcfzUi4B0cd
https://wakelet.com/wake/6lorVoXd6tkg2FkN30w4s
https://wakelet.com/wake/v1MVVLuWvS88GfSn1nzpS
https://wakelet.com/wake/6iOhtNEnMUeF6rTP8GUUt
https://wakelet.com/wake/UJ947Xo2LKbuNkusk6CN5
https://wakelet.com/wake/FVcPIaWEJ3neydcIHeo51
http://atsamat.net/component/k2/item/73-2563

fa2b2797482/movie-Jail-free-download.pdf
https://holmidistli.weebly.com/uploads/1/3/6/5/136529454/f1-chall
enge-delux-2009-download-do-jogogratis.pdf
https://vdocuments.mx/native-instruments-session-horns-kontaktmag
netrixx.html
https://mextdandtrasbat.weebly.com/uploads/1/3/6/4/136477655/shud
dh-desi-romance-movie-free-download-mp4.pdf
https://uploads.strikinglycdn.com/files/fd106877-7d78-406e-ab0d-5
a006fd96c9a/Holt-McDougal-Algebra-1-Student-Edition-2012-download
-pdf.pdf
http://nikuhizuho.tistory.com/47
https://fundsembmace.storeinfo.jp/posts/18804100
https://uploads.strikinglycdn.com/files/b67a923e-05c0-4145-b2dd-a
6fb69b50bbc/archicad14crackwindows732bit.pdf
https://didslolotig1988.wixsite.com/guipredtharting/post/autocad-
mechanical-2014-64-bit-crack-torrent-download
https://crucperome.amebaownd.com/posts/18804095
https://www.studiorotelli.com/larticolo-2645-ter-c-c-gli-effetti-
sul-patrimonio-del-vincolo-di-destinazione/

https://coub.com/profesmilcei/stories
https://coub.com/revecfete/stories
https://coub.com/rarimtyno/stories
https://coub.com/snakcosicfoa/stories
https://coub.com/ponabhighcup/stories
https://coub.com/itceripho/stories
https://coub.com/laufealifor/stories
https://coub.com/quibevare/stories
https://coub.com/esbumisderm/stories
https://www.maarheeze.nu/index.php/component/k2/item/4557-kindero
ptocht-brede-school-de-muzenberg-trapt-carnaval-af

https://wakelet.com/wake/z3hbD19X-QdYtIL8Xhcsi
https://wakelet.com/wake/Ls4j5Tri5X61kbruCV62z
https://wakelet.com/wake/W9dHD3Sp_4D4F0VsOkDg9
https://wakelet.com/wake/UmYadx540mpHeH4dPunRS
https://wakelet.com/wake/h1EPMKO5D46xS-ALiPe-A
https://wakelet.com/wake/eCjoW8nZK_oNe62qBCBaF
https://wakelet.com/wake/aW6KbxYxkFc9yChPNo9BG
https://wakelet.com/wake/yhOWSM2kzprP1lrTRctii
https://wakelet.com/wake/EVRRaGYBiskWM_WSSisZq
http://ginjirouh.sblo.jp/article/188927418.html

load-portable-with-license-key
https://coub.com/stories/3251369-work-europe-2011-2012-edition-1-
0-harman-becker-citroen-c5
https://coub.com/stories/3251367-download-harvest-moon-the-movie-
gritty-reboots-15-patpam
https://coub.com/stories/3251368-arrival-english-telugu-movie-vid
eo-songs-hd-1080p
https://coub.com/stories/3251365-high-quality-u-me-aur-hum-movie-
3gp-download-dubbed-in-hindi
https://coub.com/stories/3251364-the-film-movie-in-hindi-720p-dow
nload-work
https://coub.com/stories/3251363-download-net-framework-3-5-inclu
de-2-0-and-3-0-for-windows-8-rapidshare-__link__
https://coub.com/stories/3251362-download-link-animasi-xxx-berger
ak-gratis
https://coub.com/stories/3251361-george-crumb-black-angels-score-
pdf-better
https://coub.com/stories/3251356-selfhealbydesigntheroleofmicroor
ganismsforhealthbybarbaraoneilldownloadepubmobipd-filizebu
https://okadol.jimdofree.com/2013/03/28/%E7%A6%8F%E6%99%BA%E5%B1%
B1-%E8%99%8E%E5%B0%BE%E6%A1%9C-2013-3-26/

https://wakelet.com/wake/MMjNVBWmuNac6kG6gLMoM
https://wakelet.com/wake/8tKzq6FaolpiYiOGBjJPo
https://wakelet.com/wake/P79um3VBXZGzVfnRtkkML
https://wakelet.com/wake/XTbVGxrsqtNqdLGbNtkRI
https://wakelet.com/wake/ogm7gmyPvOcJp0vLa4Dag
https://wakelet.com/wake/pzgc0s3_AhGVDOEaOn7UL
https://wakelet.com/wake/BXAr-cIEvV__1FVtnAiGc
https://wakelet.com/wake/89jSnx_c8Y3dfGmWZDEbp
https://wakelet.com/wake/Htbd-X_9necgDsUC7fTWQ
http://johntravisduncan.com/portfolio/yosemite/

https://wakelet.com/wake/30CfQQouMqzPBNBJgCHsj
https://wakelet.com/wake/wcX2Je9MYfY2xzuB6ggzD
https://wakelet.com/wake/VrqHSnyX6uF3H8EzLWtM1
https://wakelet.com/wake/vnsfEMQK3iijG2ABimVpv
https://wakelet.com/wake/rPH8bCGV5K8prHu-HywmT
https://wakelet.com/wake/PHBLY8XHD50bjcDNCei8J
https://wakelet.com/wake/qobaaywjo0dee_2PPR2uk
https://wakelet.com/wake/gxBvoW_4LIjflhZEZ3FVC
https://wakelet.com/wake/s5em3U65d6WGamFIbhG9J
https://viptravel.am/hy/component/k2/item/21-vivamus-eu-urna-pret
ium-nisi-tincidunt/21-vivamus-eu-urna-pretium-nisi-tincidunt?r=p

lajar-tulungagung
https://coub.com/stories/3347866-dan-hartman-torrent-discography
https://coub.com/stories/3347864-asana-andiappan-yoga-book-downlo
ad-zevobad
https://coub.com/stories/3347863-euro-truck-simulator-2-117-17-cr
acked
https://coub.com/stories/3347862-nero-para-windows-8-gratis-porta
ble
https://coub.com/stories/3347859-hot-drivebox-rfactor-mod-project
-d-initial-d-ultimate-stage-pack
https://coub.com/stories/3347857-coremelt-lock-and-load-x-crack-f
avvill
https://coub.com/stories/3347858-intuit-quickbooks-point-of-sale-
v8-0-multistore-beast-download-haroian
https://coub.com/stories/3347856-www-malayalam-aunty-sex-videos-c
oml
https://coub.com/stories/3347855-piscina-bione-lecco-orari-nuoto-
libero-elliwre
https://forums.hotciti.com/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=372023&p=1682390#p1682390

ditor-portable
https://coub.com/stories/3246908-the-cell-2000-720p-bluray-x264-b
esthd-top
https://coub.com/stories/3246907-splinter-cell-blacklist-crack-mu
ltiplayer-top-download
https://coub.com/stories/3246909-free-zombi-kampung-pisang-full-m
ovie-405
https://coub.com/stories/3246910-ship-simulator-extreme-skidrow-1
3-tannant
https://coub.com/stories/3246912-gopal-bhar-videos-3gp-mobil-_hot
_
https://coub.com/stories/3246913-xforce-keygen-advance-steel-2015
-64bit-free-download-link
https://coub.com/stories/3246911-best-martin-lindstrom-brandwashe
d-epub-11
https://coub.com/stories/3233982-bios-psx-scph1000-bin-link
https://coub.com/stories/3233978-tirupathi-express-kannada-full-m
ovie-free-11-hot
https://mmanime.org/tvshows/anonymous-noise/

https://wakelet.com/wake/KH_UltILHD1lfHBYpzJfR
https://wakelet.com/wake/VUeybsc7WIjWyWAC0GjZJ
https://wakelet.com/wake/EsY77b5TMVCbBRovLhgvq
https://wakelet.com/wake/feACGRiK1AVmHF1OpRkg_
https://wakelet.com/wake/jP6LyfWWOjAHWHjO6HbAz
https://wakelet.com/wake/5-9j8m7RWyXWoiblYblCK
https://wakelet.com/wake/gl2NO6GXi_3BvHimdUNSh
https://wakelet.com/wake/cyE4iop9vXOS10A59ihWc
https://wakelet.com/wake/ZesWhDE35LLXAGj6wnwxO
https://www.sakeneravan.ir/index.php?option=com_k2&view=item&id=1
42:about-site&Itemid=330
Oops!
Oops, you forgot something.